|
By Victoria Bender, Bender Law Offices, PC
In North Carolina, courts of this state having jurisdiction over the parties, can equitably divide marital property.
(NCGS 50-20). Marital property includes all real and personal property acquired during marriage and before separation and presently owned by the parties. While the statutes further state that, AReal
or personal property located outside of North
Carolina is subject to equitable distribution in
accordance with the provisions of G.S. 50-20, and
the court may include in its order appropriate
provisions to ensure compliance with the order of
equitable distribution.;(a) NGCS 50-21(a). Carroll v Carroll 88 NCApp 453, 363 SE2d 872 (1988), it is not always easy to enforce an award for distribution of property that is located in a foreign jurisdiction. When a court in North Carolina speaks of a foreign jurisdiction, that term applies to other states as well as other countries.
North Carolina and most other states make a legal distinction between matters which are
"in rem" and those which are "in personam". An in rem action means that the property itself is located within the state (such as land) while
"in personam" means that the court is asserting its power over a person, not a thing. Any attempt by a court to assert title to property in another state is void. "[s]o much of the foreign] judgment as attempts to affect the title to [North Carolina property], ... is a nullity.");
Kirstein v. Kirstein, 64 N.C.App. 191, 193, 306 S.E.2d 552, 553 (1983) (holding "to the extent that the foreign] decree attempt[s] to affect title to property in North Carolina, it is void.");
Courtney v. Courtney, 40 N.C.App. 291, 297, 253 S.E.2d 2, 5 (1979) (holding that "any part of a foreign decree which attempted to determine ultimate title to North Carolina realty [is]void." Instead, a court may order a person over whom it has jurisdiction to do an act, such as convey the real property located in the other state.
Buchanan v. Weber 152 N.C.App. 180, 567 S.E.2d 413 (2002). So long as the court had the power over the person it could make an effective order by carefully drafting an order.
More complex are matters with an international
scope. Assuming a party obtains a valid order in
North Carolina, it would have to be enforced in a
foreign country. The first step is to make sure the
property is in the other country. Any financial
account numbers, copies of titles or real estate
records will assist you in your search. Once it is
determined that the property does exist, it may be
possible to
"freeze" the assets by seeking an order
from the local court. If you have a North Carolina
order freezing the assets and it is property
certified with the apostille affixed, a foreign
entity such as a bank, particularly a bank which
does business in the United Sates, may honor the
order on a short term basis while an appropriate
order is being obtained locally. Check with the
State Department to ascertain whether there are any
international treaties which may control your
ability to proceed. While there is a large and
complex international treaty known as the Hague
Convention which is often referred to in Child
Custody matters, the United States has signed only
certain parts of the document and has not signed the
sub part known as the Hague Convention on the
Recognition of Divorces and Legal Separations.
Atassi v Atassi117 N.C.App. 506, 451 S.E.2d
371. The United States and each individual
state is hesitant to allow foreign judgments to be
enforced here as the foreign courts may not afford
the litigants the same due process rights as are
required by our courts. Conversely, foreign courts
whose judgments are not honored here will often
refuse to honor the judgments and orders of our
courts.
That does not mean that you are without a remedy if
you have a North Carolina judgment. The first step
is to certify the judgment and obtain an apostille
from the Secretary of State. This document, with the
apostille is then presented to the courts of the
foreign country for enforcement. Often times the
best means of proceeding is through local counsel.
Both the United States Office of Consular Services
in the foreign country and the consulate office of
the foreign country here in the United States can
offer assistance in finding appropriate counsel and
in enforcing the order obtained. In almost all
cases, the association of competent local counsel is
the best way to obtain a satisfactory result. It may
be necessary to file an action in the foreign
country to proceed with discovery of information and
enforcement of the order. Be aware, however, that in
many countries it is difficult, time consuming, and
costly to obtain a satisfactory result. Whenever
possible, a party is best off to be awarded assets
located in the United States.
While the IRS has held that transfers of property
incident to divorce are not a taxable event, other
countries may not have the same law and there may be
unknown tax ramifications. Similarly, it may not be
possible to remove property or currency from the
foreign location.
International property distribution is a complex and
daunting matter even for the most experienced family
law attorneys. If your matter includes foreign
assets and international issues you would be best to
make your counsel aware of these facts as soon as
possible so that appropriate action can be taken to
find and preserve these assets for valuation and
distribution.
|
|
|
Copyright © 2005 Bender Law Offices P.C., All Rights
Reserved.
Divorce Lawyers, Separation Attorneys, Family Law,
International Divorce, Mediation, Agreements, Child
Custody, Court Services, Alimony, Domestic Violence,
Child Support, Property Distribution, Spousal
Support
|
|